I consistently power down my mobile device as I step into a cinema. Not just on do not disturb – totally powered down. I state this not from a place of judgment, or in the hope that the specter of Billy Wilder will return to congratulate me. I consider it as a simple small luxuries: for no less than a couple of hours, I become totally incommunicado. I leave my phone off throughout the scroll as well. It feels luxurious to stay put as other patrons slowly filter out, lit only by the rolling text.
And, more and more, by the glow of the Letterboxd app.
In excess of millions of users utilize Letterboxd, a movie-logging app. Similar to A24, it has evolved into industry shorthand for a specific type of tastemaker who hypes new releases and finds joy in rediscovering cinematic treasures. Members score and write about films, and the funniest or most articulate critiques become popular, incentivizing film lovers to put in effort.
"If I don't get my thoughts out quickly when the film concludes, my reviews are significantly less clear and eloquent," remarked a student.
On a recent visit to the cinema, the credits had barely started before the man ahead of me commenced writing his review. Nearby, a couple sat, heads bowed, jotting down their respective thoughts.
The late film-maker David Lynch had a piece of wisdom: record every brilliant thought the exact moment it strikes you. Otherwise, it could vanish, and, in his words: "If you forget a valuable thought, it makes you want to commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to aspiring film-makers, a similar ethos fits the post-film ritual.
One young man, a 20-year-old university attendee in New York, always drafts his reviews while still in the cinema.
"Should I fail to get my thoughts out immediately once the movie ends, my critiques are far less clear and eloquent," he explained. "It requires some time. I take my time, and my partner isn't fond of it."
Stern attends the movies frequently – 182 visits last year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who occasionally must usher him out so they can start tidying the rows. He thinks it reasonable to milk the credit sequence: "When you pay for a theater ticket, the closing sequence are included in the film experience."
Letterboxd's most passionate supporters attribute the platform with reinvigorating excitement around a battered cinema sector, where fewer films are made and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also boasts the sort of demographics advertisers seek – its biggest segment of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Hype generates further excitement; much-hyped movies see a rash of activity on Letterboxd right after the premiere showtimes. The highest-rated review of an acclaimed adaptation – "the author passed away in the 19th century yet this version is still the greatest injustice that has ever befallen her" – has amassed in excess of 50,000 likes. A different fictionalized retelling inspired this contrast to a rival's concert film: "a famous concert movie left in the dust."
"It feels like a compulsion," said Ben Glidden, a 33-year-old resident who works in marketing. He also likes to write reviews in the end sequence. "Reflecting on what you just experienced, as soon as you watched it, helps with the viewing experience. It helps you grasp the central themes of a film. If it evokes a sensation of comfort, that's hardly something you recall the next day."
Glidden feels most driven to review a film if it was brilliant – or exceptionally bad. For example: he recently endured a star-driven project. "I was actually so offended by how profoundly awful it was, that I was eager to whip out my phone and award it a one-half star review," he stated. (Glidden is a stricter critic than some professional critics, who gave the film a more favorable review, labeling it "smart and entertaining material.")
Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old New Yorker who works in social media, saw an acclaimed animated film at a local theater and remained to draft the review ("I gave it a perfect score"). He has observed worse behavior: people whipping out their phones to review the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That behavior gets on my nerves," he commented.
One of film's most enduring urban legends tells of a exhibition of an early motion picture that featured a train arriving at a station. Cinema was in its formative period and – according to this largely discredited story – the footage of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera frightened the spectators so much that people scattered in terror.
Over a century later, audience behavior remains just as questionable. Often, no one remember how to behave in a theater any more, particularly when the lights dim: audience members take pictures of the screen, bring in smelly food, and, as was reported during a blockbuster summer, occasionally get into physical altercations.
Some individuals have turned to social media to argue over the acceptability of "Letterboxding" in the closing scroll. When one social media user